REVIEWS
7

OVERALL
VERDICT

The Top Gear car review:

Mahindra Scorpio 2.2CRDe 4WD S11

R394 999

Ntsako Mthethwa
July 8, 2022
No items found.

Review: Mahindra Scorpio S11 is 'old-school' but capable

7

OVERALL
VERDICT

For:

Spacious, frugal, superb powerplant

Against:

Tech is lacking, compromised boot space, no automatic transmission

What is it?

When talking SUVs, the Mahindra Scorpio has always been part and parcel of the Indian marque and has, surprisingly, been around longer than either of the ladder-frame SUV stalwarts bearing the Toyota Fortuner and Ford Everest names.

In 2002, Mahindra decided to build a car that'd compete in the global market. Decision and action, though, proved to be polar opposites, and due to the limited technical knowledge concerning SUV-building, the Indian carmaker had to seek assistance. Mahindra outsourced all the Scorpio's major systems to suppliers while it solely focused on the design, performance specifications, and program cost of the SUV. And that's how the Scorpio came about.

Still in its first generation, the Scorpio's steady refinements since 2002 have kept it reinvigorated, and luckily, at the time of penning this down, Mahindra had announced the Scorpio-N, which will replace the current model.

I received the robust Scorpio S11 4WD just in time for a family road trip to the Kruger National Park. As a rugged-looking SUV, the Scorpio stands tall and sinister while bearing an old-school stance that, if I am honest, has become synonymous with farmers, and outdoor aficionados. For the most part, the Scorpio raked in the distance to Mpumalanga with so much simplicity.

Next: Driving
>

Layout, finish and space

As far as bakkie-based SUVs are concerned, the Scorpio S11 doesn't have any natural local competitors with space suited to accommodating eight passengers with relative ease. However, with the third row of seats up, the boot space is compromised, which wasn't ideal when loading road trip necessities.

On the tech front, the Scorpio isn't exactly at the cutting-edge of equipment. Understandable, I suppose. You get a 7" touchscreen infotainment system with a single USB port, Bluetooth connectivity, an auxiliary jack, an HD reverse camera, cruise control, and a multi-functional steering wheel. It ends there. There's no Apple CarPlay, or Android Auto-smartphone pairing, nor usable storage spaces – not a welcome surprise considering the nature of the assignment.

Positives? Yes, of course. The interior is solidly built, thanks to coarse fabrics, semi-leather upholster and front foldable armrests which added a level of comfort during the 400 km+ stint to Mpumalanga. Also, the driver's seat gives a commanding view of the road ahead and surrounds through the sizeable windshield.

<
Next: Driving
>

What is it like on the road?

The mHawk 2.2-litre four-cylinder turbodiesel engine has always been Mahindra's ace in the deck, in large part due to its nippy disposition and frugality. Paired with a 6-speed manual transmission, the powerplant churns out 103 kW of power and 280 Nm of torque – modest, sure, but adequate for hauling the behemoth even when laden with eight passengers.

The Scorpio's engine is also not unreasonably harsh on the senses – on either the vibration, or noise fronts – with the bonus of a linear power delivery curve that lives beyond the 3,000 r/min mark. Driving around the Kruger National Park, the 50 km/h speed limit proved problematic, though. The gearing speed on the manual gearbox isn't ideal for maintaining the speed limit, with the Scorpio occasionally stuttering to a halt thanks to a stall. An automatic transmission would've certainly been better-suited to this task.

Overall, the Scorpio's ride quality isn't its most favourable trait. The suspension barely buffers the cabin from road imperfections, further affirming my view that it's not designed for opulence but for an outdoor lifestyle. Ditto with the amount of wind noise penetrating the cabin at highway cruising speeds because of its not-so-aerodynamic shape.

<
Next: Owning
>

Running costs and reliability

Mahindra's Scorpio is billed as the SUV that blends rugged delights with a pinch of modern technology, and for the past 20 years, that's remained true.

Around the Kruger, clinging religiously to the speed limit, the Scorpio proved to be frugal at 6.1l/100 km. On the open road, the numbers wafted around the 7.9l/100 km mark, which is quite impressive for a car tipping the scales at 1,925 kg.

While a price tag of R394,999 for this particular model may be startling at a time when shoppers tend to dig deeper into their pockets for an off-road capable model, it also comes standard with a comprehensive 4-year/120,000 km mechanical warranty and a full 5-year/90,000 km service plan.

<
Next: Verdict
>

Final thoughts

In essence, the Scorpio leaves much to be desired; an automatic transmission, additional modern attributes, and a softer suspension setup. However, its eager engine, ability to carry eight passengers with aplomb, and traditionally-styled butch pose make up for the snags.

With the new Scorpio-N earmarked for our market, we'll certainly value and appreciate the extra sting in its tail.

<
Newsletter

Get Top Gear SA news and reviews in your inbox

Enter your email address to receive regular Top Gear SA newsletters

By clicking below you agree to receive news, promotions and offers by email from Top Gear SA. Your information will be used in accordance with our privacy policy.

Verify Your Email
To be part of the PETROLHEAD club please verify the email that has been sent to you.
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

ELECTRIC

Newsletter

Get Top Gear SA news and reviews in your inbox

Enter your email address to receive regular Top Gear SA newsletters

By clicking below you agree to receive news, promotions and offers by email from Top Gear SA. Your information will be used in accordance with our privacy policy.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

MORE TOP GEAR SOUTH AFRICA